Submit a question to our community and get an answer from real people.
Submit

Hello mods, just to make sure my answer was not removed due to reference to a non-christian religion was it?

the question was Does Jesus die again every Mass?

Report as
This user is an Ask Community moderator.
This answer contributed to Susan G. Komen for the Cure® What's this?
This user is an Ask Community moderator.
My answers support Susan G. Komen for the Cure® What's this?

morderdbas, no the question was most likely removed because it was a Yes/No question, which is considered a "Poll" and not allowed. Try rephrasing it so that people would be more inclined to give a detailed answer

Helpful (1) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (13)
Report as
Nope it was not a yes/no question and it was an answer not a question. It contained no profanity, words of ill-repute or negative opinion. The only thing I think some people may have found offensive was a positive reference to a non-Christian religion
Report as
Deana my answers seemed to also be removed. I see you are the mod on duty.
Report as
But the people do not decide what questions are removed. So simply because some people flag a question, or an answer does not get it removed.
Report as
Sorry Morderedbas, I misunderstood I thought the Q you posted there was the content that was removed... I am not sure what exactly was removed as I didn't remove it, it would be best if you contacted Customer Support about this one
Report as
Deanna is it possible that atheists answers are removed more frequently than religious answers?
Report as
I am not aware of it if so, I do not do so but I don't monitor what the other moderators do, we are only supposed to remove things which violate the rules or which are rude/offensive toward other members. I would highly doubt our other moderators do this, they are all very professional.
Report as
Some people are more easily offended than others so that is a fine line that the moderators must traverse. For instance, I am extremely offended by the poor grammar and misspelling that I see all the time here, but it is rarely removed ;-)
Report as
LOL Sott i mean Scott
Report as
Thank you Scott, I agree. Deanna, I'm seeing a pattern. I'm watching.
Report as
@bellydncr - I sent you an email yesterday, regarding a comment that was removed, that also contained a bit more information regarding the issue that you were commenting on - did you get it?

I ask, because what is visible to users is "oh the Atheist's comments/answers were removed, but not the Christian's", what isn't seen is what the actual comments/answers consisted of. Which in this particular case was blatant flaming and bashing of multiple people, across multiple questions. The removals had nothing to do with having a differing view on the subject - it was entirely the way they were going about expressing it, which was rude and offensive (and often punctuated with multiple f-bombs), which is not appropriate for the site, and never has been.

I would ask that you (and others) please keep that in mind, as there has been a lot of talk about "bias" issues, but users don't have the whole picture, and are often making incorrect judgements based on that limited information.

Something else that might be worth mentioning as well, is that not all religious questions are "debate" type questions. So if someone is asking about a specific aspect of their religion, and someone comes along and posts an answer that isn't addressing that specific question, then it can be removed for being off-topic. Again, it's not that there is an issue with the person's view point, it's just not the right place to be expressing it.
Report as
* I should make it clear that I was talking about the question you commented on yesterday (for which I emailed you about) - not the one referenced in this particular question. Wasn't sure if that was clear or not, and didn't want to add to the confusion.

Also, please don't read any of that in a cranky/snippy tone of voice, I definitely wasn't writing it that way, and with tone of voice so not carrying over the internet, I realized afterwards that it probably came across that way. :)
Report as
Bellydancer if you ahd actually been following the conversation you would know that I'm, Asatru not an atheist
Report as
Opps that should have been addressed to too2sweet not Bellydancer
Report as
Add a comment...

Why would jesus die again every mass? Where did u get that from

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (1)
Report as
According to the New Saint Joseph Baltimore Catechism, vol 2, question 357, "The mass is the sacrifice of the new law in which Christ, through the Ministry of the priest, offers himself to God in an unbloody manner under the appearances of bread and wine. The mass is the sacrifice of Christ offered in a sacramental manner...the reality is the same but the appearances differ." Question 358 asks "What is a sacrifice?" The answer given is "A sacrifice is the offering of a victim by a priest to God alone, and the destruction of it in some way to knowledge that he is the creator of all things." From the Baltimore catechism we can conclude that the mass is the offering of Christ, by a priest.
Report as
Add a comment...

no

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...

Don't you know what symbolism is?

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (11)
Report as
In her defense it is symbolism, no matter how you look at it.
Report as
Listen mord this is a public web site
Report as
Hi Joanie. Hope all is well.
Report as
Ooo way to change your question to make it reasonable after I unloaded.
Report as
To answer, The Eucharistic Prayer includes the epiclesis, a prayer that the gifts offered may by the power of the Holy Spirit become the body and blood of Christ. The central part is the Institution Narrative and Consecration, recalling the words and actions of Jesus at his Last Supper, which he told his disciples to do in remembrance of him. Immediately after the Consecration and the display to the people of the consecrated elements, the priest says: "The mystery of faith", and the people pronounce the acclamation, using one of the three prescribed formulae. It concludes with a doxology, with the priest lifting up the paten with the host and the deacon (if there is one) the chalice, and the singing or recitation of the Amen by the people.
Communion rite
All together recite or sing the "Lord's Prayer" ("Pater Noster" or "Our Father"). The priest introduces it with a short phrase and follows it up with a prayer called the embolism and the people respond with the doxology. The sign of peace is exchanged and then the "Lamb of God" ("Agnus Dei" in Latin) litany is sung or recited, while the priest breaks the host and places a piece in the main chalice; this is known as the rite of fraction and commingling.
The priest then presents the transubstantiated elements to the congregation, saying: "Behold the Lamb of God, behold him who takes away the sin of the world. Blessed are those called to the supper of the Lamb." Then all repeat: "Lord, I am not worthy that you should enter under my roof, but only say the word and my soul shall be healed." The priest then receives Communion and, with the help, if necessary, of extraordinary ministers, distributes Communion to the people, who usually approach in procession.
So yes the bread and wine/grape juice are transformed into the body and blood of Christ and is not a form of symbolism in the eyes of the Church.
Report as
And if you believe it, then it is true for you. For me it would just be some grape juice and a cracker...symbolic, sorry.
Report as
bellydncr. I'm just trying to keep my foot out of my mouth. It's almost working, I must have curvature of the knee.
Report as
raven. Did I miss a good one? Hey, I can take it. I've annoyed a lot of people today. It's my turn to take some flack. Thanks for having my back.
Report as
Annoy and outright disrespect are two different things.
Report as
Thanks. Sometimes, I pick up the negativity from this site and it infects my answers. Then, I feel so guilty about it, my old, sweeter self comes back. I'm such a softy, it bothers me all day to think I have hurt someone's feelings. I really appreciated your good wishes in the midst of it.
Report as
You didn't hurt my feelings you were disrespectful. Perhaps you need a break from Ask if you are getting so upset.
Report as
Add a comment...

I detect bias, surely mods are human and are guilty of this at times.

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...
Do you have an answer?
Answer this question...
Did you mean?
Login or Join the Community to answer

About - Privacy - AskEraser - Careers - Ask Blog - Q&A - Mobile - Help - Feedback ©2013 Ask.com