I think that personality is more important. If a guy can make a girl laugh that is a good sign. A person should take care of themselves appearance wise, but don't have to look like they came out of a JcPenney's catalog. Girls should always go for guys that can get them out of their shell if you know what I mean
like what SherryA said.it depends on a girl,Girl that are attracted with a good looking guys without even knowing whether the guy is in a relationship or not in a relationship,Girl that like's a guy in his attitude and the way the guy treat other people including the girl itself.