Submit a question to our community and get an answer from real people.
Submit

Do our rights come from nature and God or do they come from government?

Report as
This answer contributed to Susan G. Komen for the Cure® What's this?
My answers support Susan G. Komen for the Cure® What's this?

Technically the government via the constitution, nature provides no "rights" other then to fight and survive and god is only a belief.

Helpful (4) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (5)
Report as
Technically you are wrong. Reread the Bill of Rights. We are born with rights. Government was instituted by man to protect those rights.
Report as
It is the constitution that states we are born with rights. If civilazation collapsed and the constitution were lost forever we would not be born with rights tatooed on our butts. And you didn't include "man" in your question, if you had that would have been included that in my answer since the constitution didn't just magically appear.
Report as
The declaration, bill of rights and constitution was written by man to confirm that we are born with inalienable rights. They are there the second we are born tattooed on our butts as you say.
Report as
If our government collapsed your inalienable rights would disappear.
Report as
@ Boo As would yours. You might find the aftermath entertaining.
Report as
Add a comment...

Government...they THINK they are God(s) :(

Helpful (2) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (6)
Report as
Our rights come from nature and God. Government is there to protect the rights we are born with. Time to take our country back.
Report as
Haven't we been trying for awhile...I'm 16 and haven't seen us take it back yet :(
Report as
No we have been just letting politicians gain more power and stealing our freedoms. I am old and I do remember how things should be. It should be better for each generation and has been until now. I want you kids to live in a free country where you can pursue your own happiness and not have it given to you by government who always fails.
Report as
I was told our freedoms are being taken away more and more everyday :(
Report as
They are! Please take the time to read our Bill of Rights, Constitution and the Declaration of Independence. They are so small you can carry them around in your pocket yet are so big they have changed the world! Freedom is not just a word. It is something we all must fight to protect. Or it will be gone forever.
Report as
Twisted...pretty impressive! You make me proud sometimes.
Report as
Add a comment...

Who creates government? - Man

Who created man? - ?

God > Man > Government

Helpful (1) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (1)
Report as
Government was instituted to protect the rights we are born with not to give us rights.
Report as
Add a comment...

Both. It's called the CONSTITUTION read it some time.

Helpful (2) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...

well, God created us with rights. the government likes to think they're God but theyre not. honestly, im just glad they let us keep our rights

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (4)
Report as
Our rights ARE our freedom.
ANY freedom we give up, for WHATEVER reason, will NEVER be restored to us. This government thinks they can make better decisions about what's good for us than WE can and they want to take our rights away.
If we let them decide whether or not to purchase a 32 oz. drink, as in NY city, then they win. When THEY win, WE loose. And we loose forever. Do you think they'll stop there? Well do you?
You must be ready to protect your rights or you will surly loose them.
Report as
I'll just live in a cave underground, hiding from the government. I'll become like robin hood and break the law for good things and no one will b able to catch me!
Report as
For EVERY law passed is a freedom lost.
Report as
They do?
Report as
Add a comment...

Natural right was the idea. So the founding fathers just put it as the bill of right to keep the gov in check

Helpful (1) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...

Our founders believed in natural rights theory. Natural rights are rights not contingent upon the laws, customs, or beliefs of any particular culture or government, and therefore universal and inalienable. In contrast, legal rights are those bestowed onto a person by the law of a particular political and legal system, and therefore relative to specific cultures and governments.
Legal rights may be constitutional, statutory, regulatory, contractual, common-law, or conferred by international human rights law. Legal rights are almost always qualified, whether by implication, by the law which created the right itself or by legal rights held by others. A legal right can be enforced in courts of law against another who has infringed the right. The right may be enforced by a court order or injunction prohibiting the other person or persons from infringing a right, by the awarding of money to compensate the holder of the right. In contrast, natural rights are considered beyond the authority of any government or international body to dismiss. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights is an important legal instrument enshrining one conception of natural rights into international soft law. Natural rights were traditionally viewed as exclusively negative rights, whereas human rights also comprise positive rights.

Helpful (2) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (6)
Report as
Wow. Are you a lawyer or have you studied law? Amazing answer as usual.
Report as
Are not all those laws supposed to protect the rights we are already born with? Our rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness?
Report as
I am humbled
Report as
Me too Grande.
Report as
My son is a lawyer. I was an economics & music double major at UCLA but took a LOT of political science classes.
But I research also research answers.
Report as
There would be nothing without God.
Report as
Add a comment...

Unfortunately our government believes in a higher power, themselves. We lose more rights every year while the government just keeps on expanding & letting us know what is good for us. It's the same garbage all the time, only the faces change. Nature & God are separate entities in America they have no bearing or effect on laws here, sadly either do the people. Folks think that the government works for them, when was the last time any government official, anywhere, had a clue as to what's going on. We have elected officials that believe they know what's best for us, they must be gods to know what we want without asking us

Helpful (2) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (1)
Report as
The one in the White House thinks he is.
Report as
Add a comment...

The answer to your question can be found in the Declaration of Independence. I suggest you read it. Then read it to your relatives, friends and neighbors. Read it 'till you understand it. If you have kids, read it and explain it to them. If you don't then volunteer to read it and explain it to your friends kids. It obviously is not being taught or explained in the schools.

Helpful (1) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (4)
Report as
I carry one in my purse and refer to it often. Thank you for reminding others to do the same. It is the most beautiful and important document ever made by men, who's idea was freedom for all people and has succeeded in raising people out of poverty and has made it possible for us to feed the world with freedom. Thanks for your answer.
Report as
I also hope they read exactly what these men went through in signing this document. They lost their fortunes, their homes and their families to dare to declare we are free people. There is a wonderful speech that Rush Limbaugh's (yes Rush!) father gave that spells out the sacrifices these men went through. You might be able to google it as I am on my phone.
Report as
Please put the flag in it's correct position. You have it in a sign of distress!
Report as
If you don't think this country is in distress with this Progressive government , then you're just not paying attention!
Report as
Add a comment...

Rights like, the right to vote, or rights like the right to live?

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (1)
Report as
All our rights. If govt says we have a right it is because we gave them the right to tell us. Otherwise they are there to protect our rights not give us new rights like the right to healthcare (as nice as that sounds) We are not born with that right any more than we have the right to live forever.
Report as
Add a comment...

I agree it's...

Both!

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator (aka: God) with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.--That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed."

Helpful (1) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (4)
Report as
That's good.
Report as
Not just good it's absolutely perfect.
Report as
Only our rights do not come from government. We give them their right to govern us.
Report as
You know "consent of the governed"?
Report as
Add a comment...

We wouldn't be having this discussion without God. We the people are the government. We just need to remind Washington of this fact. They work for us. We don't work for them. But they don't get it.

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...
Do you have an answer?
Answer this question...
Did you mean?
Login or Join the Community to answer
Popular Searches

About - Privacy - AskEraser - Careers - Ask Blog - Q&A - Mobile - Help - Feedback ©2013 Ask.com