Whats the best way to remove waterproof eyeliner without leaving my eyes red
ULTA sells liquid eyeliner remover, ask someone there or at another makeup store and they'll have the right product for you.
Get makeup remover wipes. That will take off any type of makeup.
Use nutrigena make up remover wipes it's really soft and feels really smooth and nice for you skin. Or if you want to use something with less chemicals use extra virgin olive oil.