Submit a question to our community and get an answer from real people.
Submit

Why do jehovas witnesses say philosophy is evil?

A woman came to my house preaching her religion, I mention philosophy, she says that is EVIL. Can you say brainwashed? lol...

Report as
This answer contributed to Susan G. Komen for the Cure® What's this?
My answers support Susan G. Komen for the Cure® What's this?

They don't want people to question the universe........

May make some unbelievers out of them.

Helpful (6) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (2)
Report as
Stars!
Apparently a theme in religions is "ACCEPT WHAT WE SAY WITHOUT QUESTIONING"
Curiousity and intuition are our best tools! Groupthink can lead to many faults...
Report as
Concur
Report as
Add a comment...

Jehovah's witnesses say that Philosophy, Christmas, birthday celebrations, and many other things are evil based upon the proposition presented by their faith saying that they cannot learn other subjects, and are a sola scriptura religion.

Helpful (4) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (2)
Report as
:) stars !
Report as
Concur
Report as
Add a comment...
Lollipopslove

Haha evil? That sounds crazy xP

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...

I don't believe that is part of their official teachings.
I know a few JWs, and discuss philosophy with them regularly.

Helpful (3) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (4)
Report as
I do not know about their teachings.
I had a direct experience where a very polite woman visited my home (and has done so for many years) trying to get me to go to her Jehovas Witnes Church.
When I told her I was reading philosophy and showed her the book, she opened her bible? (or religious book) and found a verse that stated something to the fact "Beware the philosophers tongue for which he will weave a web of lies...." blah blah blah....
I found it funny that her "book" had a built-in safety mechanism that tells others not to think openly or challenge authority....
Report as
That's not just in the JW version. The standard bible has scores of phrases condemning the wisdom "of this world" and how anyone that rejects their god is "foolish"- got to keep the sheep from straying, after all.
Report as
Skepti ... but you know, just because it's in the Bible doesn't make it part of any sect's official teachings. If it did, there wouldn't be hundreds of sects of Christianity.

LOL
Report as
LOL!
I love the sheep straying description.
Why do religious leaders prefer to see their followers (victims?) every week? Because messages are judged by recency as much as relevance. Hear the same stuff weekly and eventually you just might believe it.
... Like DeBeers ads saying diamonds are rare and expensive....not that anybody profits off of selling diamonds...... HAHA
Report as
Add a comment...

The creator of the religion was the brother of satanists, so maybe if they had holidays or philosophical stuff they didn't want to relate.

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (4)
Report as
Idk what the hell I just said
Report as
Maybe philosophy !! Ha ha
Report as
Lol, the creator of religion is in fact, Satan.
Report as
Well said.
Report as
Add a comment...

answer to your quest-indeed they are brain washed and trying to brain wash others

Helpful (2) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...

they are very religious, and philosophy questions that.

they also do not celebrate Halloween

I guess they dont like strange people coming up to their door and asking for things

Helpful (3) Fun (5) Thanks for voting Comments (2)
Report as
:)
Awesome!
You have identified a Paradox!
They, as strangers, come to your door asking you to change your ENTIRE BELIEF SYSTEM but...
They do not want little kids asking for a PIECE OF CANDY.
I believe the piece of candy will do less harm.... :)
Report as
LoLz
Report as
Add a comment...

Probably for the same reason many Christians believe the earth is flat or that bats are birds.

Helpful (2) Fun (2) Thanks for voting Comments (13)
Report as
You mean it is not on a turtles back?
Report as
The Bible is not meant to be a scientific description of modern biological categories. Instead, it is often written from the perspective of what we see. In other words, it makes generic categorizations. In this case, the bat is categorized as a bird because like birds, it flies and is similar in size to most birds. If we did not know that it was a mammal, it would be natural to call it a bird. To the Hebrew of ancient times, calling it a bird was perfectly logical. But, in modern times we categorize animal species more specifically, and have categorized the bat as a mammal and not a bird.
Also, we must be aware that it is modern science that has a different classification system than ancient times. To the ancients, creatures such as a bat were considered birds since they categorized all flying animals as birds. If that is the category that they used, then they were correct. It is not an error. It is a difference of categorization procedures. The critic has imposed upon the ancient text a modern system of categorization and then said that the Bible is wrong. This is a big error in thinking.http://carm.org/bible-difficulties/genesis-deuteronomy/bat-bird
Report as
Christians believe the earth is flat?!
Report as
I haven't met one Christian that thinks these things haha oh my gosh. You must hang out with some STUPID Christians.
Report as
I thought it was on the shoulders of some guy named Atlas.
Report as
The bible also claimed the sun revolves around the Earth and demons cause disease.

Which was pretty par for the course for the desert tribes of the time, but the problem comes in when people claim the bible is 100% literal and inerrant. If it's literal, there is no playing santo a games with interpretation. Can't have it both ways.
Report as
Semantic. What the heck, autocorrect?
Report as
7mercy7, Isaiah says that the world is a circle, not a sphere or globe. The original Hebrew translation is "circle", and yes, the Hebrews DID know the difference. Isaiah also compares the world to the floor of a tent--which reaffirms that the intention is to convey a flat surface, rather than a sphere.


As for the bat, the book of Leviticus says that bats are unclean birds and you should not eat them.
Report as
You must hang out with Christians who reject science.
Report as
@straw, do you believe bats are birds?
Report as
In 2013, I know a bat is a mammal, But to someone back then, a bat flew like a bird.
Report as
Then you cannot claim the bible is 100% accurate and literal. Literal means you don't get to interpret things however you like.
Report as
Then stop saying that the Bible is the true inspired word of God because your God would have known (even if it's 6000 yrs ago) that bats are not birds.
Report as
Add a comment...

Colossians 2:8 "See to it that no one takes you captive through hollow and deceptive philosophy, which depends on human tradition and the basic principles of this world rather than Christ." (New international Bible)
Also (1 Corinthians 1:20) "So what about these wise men these scholars, these brilliant debaters of this world's great affairs? God has made them all look foolish, and shown their wisdom to be useless nonsense." (Living Bible). "The world around us is under Satan's power and control." [ 1 John 5:19] (LivingBible). Everyone has choices to make, and give their option.
personally I like to answer from the Bible.

Helpful (4) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (3)
Report as
Wisdom comes from God!
Report as
Yes, I agree 100%.
Report as
Blind obedience is awesome! The blind following the blind!
Report as
Add a comment...

One question to ask JW: which Jesus do you worship( they do not worship the Jesus of the NT. they dont believe Jeaus IS GOD! they just think He is/was Michael the ArchAngel.)
Some of their beliefs derive the thinking that holidays(Christmas:is/are pagan -sun moon stars are hung on trees=paganworship. / Easter : pagan = egg/ bunny are derived from god/idol worship)
Personally, i have a tree that is full of memories which i do NOT WORSHIP!
Philosophy probably questions all beliefs!
They are instructed to never question their instructors-leaders.
Acts of the New Testament instructs all believers to search the scriptures daily . For Scripture is for rebuke, counceling, instruction!
The JW are so misslead that it is hard to talk to them!
So i ask for 10 minutes of my time to speak first!
Like scripture says: dust off your shoes and move on! Dont throw your purles to swine! ( but then i think
" they are souls too-and God still loves them"--- even though he will have to judge them one day!

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (7)
Report as
I also do not celebrate Halloween!
It is totally wrong-pagan-of Satan.
Not even necessary(just commercial gain for candy and costumes and dentists!!
Report as
I hate to tell you but Christmas and Easter are pagan holidays the church stole in the fourth century to get converts, and Halloween has nothing to do with your Satan (who pagans don't even believe in).
Report as
Can somebody explain to me how Churches are built with such grand features, tapestries, golden domes, fine cloths, rich/wealthy priests, yet.....it does not in itself participate in commercial gain?
Can you explain to me the religious/televised marathons asking for money for god?
Can you explain to me the tithing some people pay? 10% or whatever?
why pay a god that is not proven to exists for some priest to get rich and (possibly) sexually assault young ones in the church (who are told not to question authority) cough cough catholic church cough..
Care to explain these?
Care to explain donation plates?
Shouldn' t the church rely on gods (doesnt exist) good will and not on money from the people of the earth?
odd....the church seems to revolve an awful lot around money.......
Report as
You're not a true Christian and you do not worship the true Jesus. That's hilarious! I love your reasoning!!!
Report as
Skepti----pagan holidays are for the pagans!
If i choose to use that same date to celebrate a birth or a death of ANYONE,that doesnt mean i'm a pagan ! It just happened that Christ WAS NOT born in Dec, and the Christians choose that time ( a Roman holiday) so they could celebrate His birth and not be noticed and persicutes in that day( got it now?)
You have to understand the Reason for the season( notsanta/not bunny/not eggs---)- but Jesus only!
Report as
Every tradition you associate with Christmas is pagan. Have a tree? Pagan. Feast? Pagan. Lights? Pagan. Gifts? Pagan. Red and green, evergreen decorations, Yule log, caroling, mistletoe? Pagan.
Celebrating birthdays is pagan in the first place- a Roman custom. The Zhenrews didn't do it. So the whole concept is pagan.


And no- Christmas was not snagged by the Church until the fourth century- when CHRISTIANS were the ones DOING the persecuting. It's a historical fact that your Jesus was grafted on to Saturnalia not to "hide" Christianity but to try and get pagan converts.

The "reason for the season" is actually the winter solstice. Of in the case of Easter (even named for a pagan goddess), the vernal equinox.
Report as
You got it skept.:-)
Report as
Add a comment...

JW's don't even believe that Jesus is God, why listen to anything they have to say?

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...
CandyCornSweetiePie

I never heard that before.

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...

Many fundamentalist sects of the Abrahamic religions discourage asking questions and critical thinking. Possibly because those questions can easily lead to lack of belief and they want to keep the sheep in line.

Helpful (3) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (2)
Report as
hi skept, i didnt get a chance to see your comment under the "women talkng too much" question because it got deleted.
Report as
I simply stated the questioner was not only pushing absurd stereotypes, but also insulting both women and men, considering his implication that men are too stupid to sit through a complete conversation.
Report as
Add a comment...

Philosophy inspires intelligence, intelligence questions interpretation, interpretations become exposed for inaccuracies, inaccuracies sink religion.

Helpful (3) Fun (1) Thanks for voting Comments (2)
Report as
star! One of the smartest things I have heard this year! :)
Report as
Woohoo! Absolutely Wonderful response! Perfectly gets two gold stars!
Report as
Add a comment...

Because there Religeon makes them evil tyrannical people and it also makes them so very mentally ill. They don't see the truth of how wonderful philosophy is, because they're gone so far.

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...

Jehovah Witnesses do not teach that - if anything they teach and promote is "free-will." They do not label or judge. However, just like any other taking in life just because one is a Jehovah Witness they may be at a level of spirituality where they need to continue to grow spiritually. Instead of degrading the organization as a whole do your research.

Hebrew 5:14 - But solid food belongs to mature people, to those who through use have their perceptive powers trained to distinguish both right and wrong.

Helpful (1) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (3)
Report as
I spent 2 years with JW- so i know how they think. I keep some of their literature so i do talk to them!
And that scripture about being spiritually feed----pertains to GOD'S Word...... To us it as the benchmark, and a ruler to measure any other false teachings / doctrines .
You dont look at a counterfit to see if its not real--- you study and learn
What the genuine looks like, then u can spot a fake!
Thats what an apologetic Christian does!
Report as
You can have any religion , be as pure as the driven snow, but if you dont BELIEVE IN the one True God and His Son Jesus, and confess and ask forgiveness..... THATS WHAT ITS ALL about!
That Jesus rose from the dead and lives---- so we too can live, if we have put out trust in Him Alone!
Thats the Gospel!
Report as
and pigs fly, and bushes burn, and ghosts haunt houses, and bigfoot roams the earth, and UFO's abduct us every day, and crop circles are real..... :P
Report as
Add a comment...

Well GYM to tell you the truth, it is really up to. If you want to choose to listen to mans philosophies, it's up to the person. It's very nice to see that Jehovah's Witnesses are talking to you about bible scriptures. I just want you to know that if we offended you we are very sorry. I see that philosophy is very dear to you, and it is a touchy subject for you. All we are trying to do is to share scripture with you.

Helpful (2) Fun Thanks for voting Comments (1)
Report as
I appreciate your sharing, and your kindness :)
For some of the people on this website, kindness = MAKE HIM A BELIEVER! which, in my eyes, does not constitute kindness...

Forcing beleifs without giving the individual a choice is pretty much coercion. I avoid that at all costs.
Again, thank you for your positive attitude. I apologize if I have offended anybody in this (or any other thread) logic on religions.
*stars*
Report as
Add a comment...

I don't know but I guarantee you philosophy it's education good stuff good concepts

Helpful Fun Thanks for voting Comments (0)
Report as
Add a comment...
Do you have an answer?
Answer this question...
Did you mean?
Login or Join the Community to answer
Popular Searches

About - Privacy - AskEraser - Careers - Ask Blog - Q&A - Mobile - Help - Feedback ©2013 Ask.com