How do I make eyeliner stay on waterline
They make eyeliner that is specifically for the waterline. Try that.
Usually I just reapply it because eye moisture clears it off. Then I look in the mirror and wonder why the heck somebody didn't tell me my eye make up was on my face!
You don't, it will not stay dry.
get the waterproof
Pencils smudge and disappear. Try using liquid eyeliner. Maybelline makes an excellent one, and I've used it for years. Keep your hands away from your eyes when you're wearing makeup, also.