Some do. Others prefer the ones with the make up. There is no single set of preferences that all guys adhere to. Whether you wear makeup or not you will attract the kind of guys who are attracted to you, as simple as that.
Well a little is good, I like just a little of eye shadow, (that stuff that Gos on your eye lashes but always freaks me out that they are going to poke the self in the eye) naked lipstick. That's good right there. I hate when girls come out looking like clowns
<--- "Chick" here, but I know men usually prefer NO make-up on a woman... or at least what THEY THINK is no make-up, haha! Most men don't care to see women with tons of make-up caked on their faces & eyes. This "natural look" (*ahem*) is achieved by wearing VERY light make-up, if you feel you need any at all. NO heavy eyeliner, eye shadow, etc. No heavy ANYthing. If you do it right, this look is what many men THINK is no make-up... ;-) A liquid/cream foundation & light powder evens out skin tone & a pale-colored blush & lip gloss will give you a "healthy glow." If you use mascara, use it very lightly, only on eyelash tips. Just enough so your eyes will be noticed. That's how mascara & eyeliner (all makeup) are meant to be used. You want your EYES to stand out, NOT your eye makeup. "Less is more"... more beautiful! Use only light make-up to enhance your beauty -- don't cover that beauty up! :)
I think my girlfriend is beautiful without any makeup. A little bit isn't bad, like the stuff around the eyes (I'm a guy, and have no knowledge of makeup), but when a girl has more makeup on than a clown, her natural beauty cannot shine through. Plus, changing your face that much is showing that you are not proud of what God has given you. I like her all the more because she is proud enough not to change what she has.