From a moms point of view, I have a 3 1/2 year old, bubbles are great. Walmart has scented ones. A doll, a barbie, a princess dress for dress up, hair "prettys" accessories, anything for drawing or coloring, Zuzu pets, or maybe even some bath toys.
A "push me popper".A dome on a handle with little colored balls inside that click when you push it and move around like popcorn popping.All 2 year olds want one. Or a nice metal spinning pump top.Just as good.
When my niece was little we gave her a toy dump truck one year. Either Tonka or Fisher Price, I forget. She loved it partly because it was so different from all the traditionally "girly" presents she got. Not sure if that helps you, but thought I'd throw it out there in case.