What does it mean when a guy tells you that your the most natural love at first sight he has ever known
That he's a natural at cheesy pick up lines, lol. How many "loves" has he had at first sight, I wonder?
Probably,you didn't wear make up,your breasts and teeth were real and you were happy the way things went,not demanding or disliking anything.
It means he thinks you are beautiful without makeup or anything just by being natural
What? I would be a little freaked by that if someone told me that just randomly, that and I'm a guy lol
He likes you, obviously for who you are.
Wow a new pick up line rated 4 out of 10. Tell him to keep on trying
Not a compliment. It could mean your a plain Jane.