I don't believe the masons believe that the eye on the top of the pyramid is anything more than a higher power of belief (in knowledge as well). Most of their symbols are just simply that symbols, they don't evoke any type of power.
It's more like the tower of Babel in the Bible. God doesn't want it and it's not his will and we are supposed to get power from God by first committing ourselves to him and learning to obey him. He'll give you power when you obey him, and when you receive the baptism of the Holy Ghost. (See Acts 1:5, 8 and 2:4).