Good hair, brown eyes (ok all eyes but i loooove brown), funny (and not a thats what she said joke...), big smile, cute laugh, good at skateboarding, and has secrets. I like to find things out about people that most wouldn't know. I like to be a friend, and have them be a friend back to me.
I look at their shoes,hair and most of all Personality! :)...i don't usually go for a guy with the same characteristics as the last...it's always different for some reason...but either way,most guys i like are my close friends.
It depends on the person. Personally I first look at personality then physical features. And sometimes when somebody has a great personality, you will start to begin to like their features, too, even if you didn't notice them before.