Can a judge overturn a jury's verdict?
Credit:Chris RyanOJO ImagesGetty Images
Q:

Can a judge overturn a jury's verdict?

A:

Quick Answer

In the United States, a judge can alter or reverse a jury's decision in certain instances. A guilty verdict may be reversed in the event of insufficient evidence from the prosecution. Overturning a verdict is known as a judgment of acquittal or a judgment notwithstanding the verdict.

 Know More

Full Answer

Overturning a verdict may happen when a motion is filed by the defense to the presiding judge. The motion is almost always denied, but the defense can file an appeal. If the judge reverses a verdict, the evidence must be examined in a manner that leans toward the prosecution. If the evidence doesn't determine guilt, the judge is compelled to reverse the guilty verdict. A judge typically doesn't overturn a not guilty verdict, because doing so would violate the Sixth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. Reversing a not guilty verdict also negates the purpose of having a trial.

Learn more about Branches of Government

Related Questions

  • Q:

    What does it mean legally when a case is date vacated by judge?

    A:

    When a judge vacates something, it means the ruling or verdict is set aside, such as an order or judgment that he finds improper. In the case of tenancy law, vacate refers to an order to move out and cease occupancy of a rental unit, according to Rottenstein Law Group.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What is jury vetting?

    A:

    Jury vetting is a term used in the United Kingdom to refer to the way in which members of a jury are checked for eligibility. There are two kinds of jury vetting: a criminal records bureau (CRB) check and an authorized jury check.

    Full Answer >
  • Q:

    How can you get excused from jury duty?

    A:

    Individuals can be excused from federal jury duty if they are members of state and local fire and police departments or public officers of local, state or federal governments, according to the United States Courts. Members of the armed forces on active duty are also excused from jury duty.

    Full Answer >
  • Q:

    How are you summoned for jury duty?

    A:

    How individuals are summoned for jury duty depends on factors such as their state of residence and to which court system they are summoned. For example, individuals summoned to jury duty with the federal courts are selected via a random pool created by names of registered voters and those with driver's licenses.

    Full Answer >

Explore