Why isn't fish considered meat?

Answer

Reasons that fish isn't considered meat for the purpose of fasting include environmental differences and the intention behind fasting. There are differing opinions based on varying interpretations of religious texts.

Although some vegetarians allow fish in their diet, the concept of allowing fish has religious roots. During Lent, Catholics are required to abstain from eating meat on Fridays, but many modern Catholic churches will hold fish fry events during Lent.

One possible reason for allowing Catholics to eat fish is because of a distinction that is made between land-locked animals, including birds, and water-dwelling creatures such as fish. Another possible reason, mentioned in the writings of Saint Thomas Aquinas, is that red meat was forbidden because it was "a great incentive to lust," a characteristic not possessed by fish. Finally, the idea that red meat came from animals that were farmed meant that abstaining from red meat involved making a sacrifice of one's property.

Q&A Related to "Why isn't fish considered meat?"
Modern practices consider meat to be the flesh of mammals and birds. Fish are considered by many to be parve, which makes them neither meat, nor a dairy food.You can find more information
http://www.ask.com/web-answers/Society/Religion_an...
The idea that fish is not meat comes from the fact that when a freshly caught fish
http://www.chacha.com/question/why-are-fish-not-co...
There are at least two separate things going on here: Some people base their diet on moral choices, in particular to avoid suffering. The closer an animal is to human, the more it
http://www.quora.com/Food/Why-is-fish-not-consider...
As a generic culinary and butchery term of art, "meat" refers to the muscular flesh of a mammal. This is the definition most commonly applied by governments in meat product
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Why_is_fish_not_consider...
Explore this Topic
because they consider animals sacred beings, capable of bearing the incarnations of gods ...
Fish are important in the balance of nature. They eat plants and animals and also become food for plants and animals. They are also considered brain food for ...
Italians have traditionally eaten seven fish on the eve of Christmas just as a way of avoiding meat before attending the midnight mass. This tradition is mainly ...
About -  Privacy -  Careers -  Ask Blog -  Mobile -  Help -  Feedback  -  Sitemap  © 2014 Ask.com