In 1999, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court adopted this approach and ruled that
the giver should ALWAYS get the ring back in a broken engagement. Iowa ...
May 15, 2013 ... Who gets the engagement ring when an engagement is broken off depends ... If
the condition does not occur, i.e., if the parties do not marry, then the gift is not ....
To get the ring back, Jack files an action to recover personal ...
That way, if the engagement is broken, the ring remains her property. ... If the
wedding's off, they say, the donor should get the ring back, regardless of why, ...
When an engaged couple breaks off the engagement, does the recipient of the
ring have to give the ring back? The answer is—depends on the circumstances of
Feb 17, 2015 ... A majority of courts find that the gift of an engagement ring contains an ... who
breaks off the engagement for a reason that has nothing to do with the ... who is
less than willing to give it back you may need a family lawyer.
Any delay by the donor in requesting the ring back will be an indication that it was
... you have suffered damages as a result of a broken engagement, you should ...
Courts have treated engagement rings in a spectrum of ways: ... If the marriage
does not happen, then the contract was broken (in legal terms, ... For example, if I
give you a sweater, I cannot come around a year later and ask for it back. Once I
Sep 25, 2012 ... If the guy breaks up, he doesn't get the ring back. But if the other party is the one
to dissolve the engagement, they have to return the ring.
However, if the man breaks the engagement, he cannot obtain the ring. ... the
man wants it back, he must be prepared to lose the argument and to have no
A: In Ohio, the majority view is that the engagement ring must be returned to you
regardless ... ring need not be returned if the engagement has been unjustifiably
broken. ... If I'm entitled to the value of the ring, does that mean I can get back the