Q:

What are some arguments against utilitarianism?

A:

There are a number of arguments against utilitarianism; many of these take issue with utilitarianism's seeming lack of concern with the principles of justice, promises and personal loyalty. Other criticisms focus on utilitarianism's apparent impracticality. Still, some detractors take issue with utilitarianism's tendency to lead one to distasteful moral decisions.

One common argument against utilitarianism is that it does not assign inherent moral significance of justice. Utilitarianism is concerned with producing the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest number of persons. There are situations when just actions contribute to optimum happiness. However, it is also conceivable that in certain situations, a person or group of people are happier by doing that which is unjust. In such a case, utilitarianism seems to favor happiness over justice.

Another common argument against utilitarianism is that it is seemingly impractical as a governing philosophy for the general body of mankind. This is because utilitarianism is chiefly concerned with happiness, or pleasure. The problem is that human beings are extremely variable; individuals have their own conceptions of the pleasurable. Thus, creating a universal way of measuring happiness is problematic.

One of the biggest issues detractors have with utilitarianism is its basic premise that pleasure and utility are the determinants of worth. In Classical philosophy, things like virtue, knowledge, wisdom and temperance are good in and of themselves. In utilitarianism, they are only good if they have a demonstrable utility; otherwise, they may be discarded.

Learn More

Related Questions

  • Q:

    When did Humanism start?

    A:

    Humanism started in 1400 as a way to attach importance to humans rather than to a divine being. According to the American Humanist Association, Humanists believe that even without religion or other supernatural beliefs, humans would have the drive and responsibility to live lives that aspire to the greater good of society.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What are examples of humanistic theory?

    A:

    Examples of humanistic theory include the need for self-actualization, focusing on the present moment and family discussions about family relationships. The belief that all individuals in the world share the same basic needs is another prominent example of humanistic theory.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    Why is it important to be honest?

    A:

    Honesty is important because it creates peace of mind and promotes relationships of trust. The benefits of honesty extend to personal health, relationships and society at large. The opposite, lying, leads to distrust, conflict, corruption and anxiety.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What are some key ethical issues facing contemporary society?

    A:

    Some key ethical issues facing contemporary society include how to provide welfare and charity support to the poor, how to deal with addiction, whether to permit euthanasia, how to treat animals and the environment and what stance to take on population control. Government corruption and wealth disparity both remain perennial ethical issues, along with society's approach to rehabilitating criminals.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:

Explore