Q:

Is it better to be feared or loved as a leader?

A:

Quick Answer

In his book, "The Prince," Niccolo Machiavelli argues that it is ultimately better to be feared than loved as a leader, although he notes that being loved and feared at the same time would be ideal, albeit unlikely. His argument is based on a view of people as essentially self-serving. If they see an opportunity to further their own interests, even at the expense of loyalty or love, only fear of repercussions will hold them back.

Know More

Full Answer

Many economists agree with Machiavelli's assessment, observing that the most powerful factor in motivating people is the fear of loss, a phenomenon referred to as "loss aversion." Economist John List suggests that employers use people's loss aversion to their advantage by issuing bonuses to employees with a warning that they will be taken back if targets are not met.

The question of whether it is better to be loved or feared as a leader is also relevant in the context of education. In former times, it was common for teachers to invoke obedience from their students by hitting them. Nowadays, it is understood that fear-based discipline, such as this stifles creativity and learning.

If creativity is a desirable trait among students or employees, then fear is not likely to be an effective tool in motivation.

Learn more about Psychology

Related Questions

  • Q:

    Why do people bite the insides of their cheeks?

    A:

    The two primary reasons why people bite the inside of their cheeks are casual bites that accidentally go the wrong way, as when one is trying to talk and eat at the same time, and a more chronic biting that comes from poorly aligned teeth, either as a result of temporomandibular joint disorder or some other dental disorder. Poorly aligned teeth cause bites to go in the wrong direction and often result in biting not only the cheek, but also the lips and tongue. The nervous responses that some people have are the third reason.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    How can you be a better listener?

    A:

    Some strategies to be a better listener include maintaining open body language, staying focused, resisting the urge to interrupt and asking questions. These techniques can improve personal listening and help others feel more engaged.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What is an example of an autocratic leader?

    A:

    Al Jazeera describes Muammar Gaddafi as an autocratic ruler, and he was known as a dictator who suppressed those who opposed his reign. He first came to power in 1969, and he ruled for over 40 years in Libya.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    Why is research better than common sense?

    A:

    Research is better than common sense because common sense is often reliant on relatively narrow and simple assumptions that are sometimes wrong. Research on the other hand is built around theories, which are constantly revised, tested and checked to ensure that they keep with proven facts.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:

Explore