Q:

Why is logic both an art and a science?

A:

Quick Answer

Logic is a liberal art as well as a science when the art form is used speculatively. Educators support this statement, saying the goal of speculative logic is to realize a truth, which also results in action. Therefore, logicians use the science of logic to direct their thinking to demonstrate a truth.

Know More
Why is logic both an art and a science?
Credit: Blend Images/Aliyev Alexei Sergeevich Brand X Pictures Getty Images

Full Answer

Cardinal Mercier of the University of Notre Dame says that logic can also be considered a practical science that directs people's thinking. Citing St. Thomas, the cardinal quotes the saint, "In speculative matters the rational dialectic science is one thing [while] . . . the demonstrative, another."

Therefore, logic, when utilized as an art, is meant to demonstrate what a person is trying to convey. Cardinal Mercier adds that some individuals, specifically those who define logic as an art, believe it is speculative rather than practical. The cardinal states that "Logic is also an art, if we understand it as being a body of rules that will guide us toward an eventual activity."

Leo Tolstoy supported the definition of logic as art by saying that this type of reasoning is contingent on one person receiving another individual's feeling of expression. So, in order to consider logic as art, an action must occur that is subordinate to a person's reasoning and thinking.

Learn more about Logic & Reasoning
Sources:

Related Questions

  • Q:

    What are some examples of sensationalism in journalism and media?

    A:

    Some of the more well-known examples of the use of sensationalism in journalism and media have been the newspaper coverage of the events leading to the Spanish-American War, the reporting on the life and death of Princess Diana and the attention given to the Casey Anthony trial. The reliance upon sensationalism in newspaper reporting began in the late 19th century as publishers William Randolph Hearst and Joseph Pulitzer battled to corner the greater share of the market for their respective publications. Sensationalism then entered the realms of radio, television, the Internet and social media as the newer forms of communication appeared and evolved.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What are equivalent sets?

    A:

    Two sets are said to be equivalent if they have the same number of elements in each set. Two equivalent sets are represented symbolically as A~B. Equal sets are always equivalent, but two equivalent sets are not always equal.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    Is imagination more important than knowledge?

    A:

    According to Albert Einstein, imagination is more important. However, there is no actual answer to this question. Philosophers have debated it for millennia, and the consensus is that one is not more important than the other. Rather, the two work together to help people form a complete experience of the world.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What is the difference between inductive and deductive logic?

    A:

    Deduction logic uses a hypothesis and examines the possibilities in order to reach a logical conclusion and inductive reasoning makes wide sweeping generalizations from a set of specific observations. The scientific method requires deductive logic to test a hypothesis and scientists also use inductive reasoning to form hypotheses.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:

Explore